Central Asian
Scientific
Journal

ӘЛЕУМЕТТІК-ЭКОНОМИКАЛЫҚ ЖӘНЕ ҚҰҚЫҚ ҒЫЛЫМДАРЫ - СОЦИАЛЬНО-ЭКОНОМИЧЕСКИЕ И ЮРИДИЧЕСКИЕ НАУКИ - SOCIO-ECONOMIC AND LEGAL SCIENCES · UDC 336.71:330.34 · English

Measuring the additionality of national development banks: a conceptual framework for emerging economies

  • Buketova Aigul Development Bank of Kazakhstan, Astana, Kazakhstan
Issue
No. 4(32), Vol. 2, 2026
Pages
191–200
Published
Nov 16, 2026
Download PDF

Abstract

National development banks are often assessed by the volume of loans they provide, even though disbursement alone does not show what economic activity occurred because of public support. Drawing on the harmonized additionality framework of multilateral development banks, research on national development banks and counterfactual evaluation methods, this article proposes a layered framework that distinguishes financial, non-financial, firm-level and systemic additionality. Each dimension is linked to observable indicators, feasible counterfactual strategies and minimum data requirements. The article addresses practical problems arising from heterogeneous projects, small samples of large borrowers, selection bias, delayed development effects and public cost, and proposes reporting labels that separate documented, plausibly causal and causally estimated claims. The framework is designed as a research agenda rather than an empirical evaluation and may be adapted to resource-dependent emerging economies.

Keywords: additionality, counterfactual evaluation, development banks, causal inference, emerging economies, impact measurement

References

  1. Additionality as a catalyst for change: insights from evaluation [Electronic resource] / European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. London : EBRD, 2025. URL: https://www.ebrd.com/home/news-and-events/publications/evaluation/ctd-additionality.html (accessed: 15.11.2026).
  2. Beck T., Klapper L. F., Mendoza J. C. The typology of partial credit guarantee funds around the world : Policy Research Working Paper No. 4771 [Electronic resource]. Washington, DC : World Bank, 2008. URL: https://documents.worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/937071468314370786 (accessed: 15.11.2026).
  3. Brown J. D., Earle J. S. Finance and growth at the firm level: evidence from SBA loans // The Journal of Finance. 2017. Vol. 72, No. 3. P. 1039–1080. DOI: 10.1111/jofi.12492.
  4. De Luna-Martínez J., Vicente C. L., Arshad A. B., Tatucu R., Song J. 2017 survey of national development banks [Electronic resource]. Washington, DC : World Bank, 2018. URL: https://documents.worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/977821525438071799 (accessed: 15.11.2026).
  5. Harmonized framework for additionality in private sector operations [Electronic resource] / Multilateral Development Banks. 2018. URL: https://www.ebrd.com/content/dam/ebrd_dxp/assets/pdfs/partnering-for-impact/harmonized-framework-additionality-2018.pdf (accessed: 15.11.2026).
  6. Lazzarini S. G., Musacchio A., Bandeira-de-Mello R., Marcon R. What do state-owned development banks do? Evidence from BNDES, 2002–09 // World Development. 2015. Vol. 66. P. 237–253. DOI: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2014.08.016.

How to cite

Buketova Aigul Measuring the additionality of national development banks: a conceptual framework for emerging economies // Central Asian Scientific Journal. – 2026. – No. 4(32), Vol. 2. – Pp. 191–200.

CC BY 4.0 Open access under the CC BY 4.0 license: you may freely read, copy and share this article, giving credit to the authors and a link to it. About the license

Reviews of this article

Leave a review

Rate the article and share your opinion. Your review appears after moderation.

Rating